• Book an appointment

  • The best day and time for me is usually

Fire risk assessor found guilty of inadequate assessment


A private fire risk assessor has been found guilty of failing to provide an adequate risk assessment to a large Newton Abbot restaurant.
A private fire risk assessor has been found guilty of failing to provide an adequate risk assessment to a large Newton Abbot restaurant.

Mr Craig Richard Stonelake was prosecuted by Devon & Somerset Fire & Rescue Service under Sections 9 and 17 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005.

Appearing at Torquay Magistrates today (25 March), Mr Stonelake had pleaded guilty was ordered to pay a total in fines and costs of £7,383.

The risk assessment Mr Stonelake had been employed to carry out was found to be unsuitable, not taking into account the sleeping risk, the inadequate means of escape, lack of suitable fire doors, inadequate fire alarm system, and inadequate firefighting equipment.

Mr Stonelake also serviced the firefighting equipment at the premises when not qualified or trained to do so and failed to service the equipment to any appropriate standard. Failing in his duty to undertake this work to an appropriate standard placed people using the premises at the risk of death or serious injury in the event of a fire occurring.

Station Manager Glen Wells said: “Anyone offering professional services to a premises, a business or a person has a responsibility and a duty of care to that business or person.

“This responsibility is at its highest and most fundamental when that work has the potential to affect the health and safety of people or employees at that premises. In the case of fire risk assessments and the servicing of emergency equipment, failures may unnecessarily expose people to the risk of death or serious injury in the event of a fire occurring.

“Where that person, with a duty of care, has failed and should reasonably have known that they did not have the requisite training, qualifications or experience for that work compounds that failure. Sadly it would appear that this particular case is not an isolated one.

“It would appear that there is a minority of people purporting to be bona fide fire risk assessors offering their services, for payment, to businesses that are unclear about the requirements of the FSO. To fail in this service provision has the potential for devastating consequences.

“It needs to be made very clear to anybody that is considering working or works in the provision of fire risk assessments and or the servicing of fire safety equipment such as fire extinguishers the seriousness of this undertaking and the need complete the work to a satisfactory standard.”

A legal requirement of the FSO and a core principle to ensuring that premises are safe in the event of a fire occurring is to have a suitable and sufficient fire risk assessment for the premises. The person responsible for the premises must ensure that it is completed up to date and available on request. The person responsible for the premises has a choice as to whether they undertake the work themselves using guidebooks that are free to download. Alternatively they may choose to employ the services of a competent fire risk assessor to undertake the work.

Orignal source - Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Service

Commercial buildings, non-domestic and multi-occupancy premises in England and Wales are already forced to undertake a 'suitable and sufficient' fire risk assessment carried out under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005.

While the overwhelming majority of premises do this, if the assessment is thought to have been carried out to an insufficient extent, the Responsible Person can face an unlimited fine or up to two years in prison.

  • Date posted:
    15/04/2015
  • Share:

View all articles



The assessor arrived on time and explained all he would be doing whilst on site completing the Fire Risk Assessment for the common areas of the twelve flats in Surrey.

Lennie D'cruz
Peet Court Residents Association, Thronton Heath, Surrey

It's particularly helpful that HASAW can complete Fire Risk Assessments, Fire Training and PAT Testing in one visit

Louise McWeeney
Connection Capital, Daventry, Northamptonshire

We have used HASAW for 10 years now and always found them to be totally reliable in producing Fire Risk Assessments and completing PAT Testing our Retail sites around the country; sometimes at short notice. Their approachable manner and communication really helps us to ensure we comply with current legislation

Kevin Doe
Tobar Group Ltd
  • Book an appointment

  • The best day and time for me is usually

© 2018 Help and Safety at Work | Fire safety, fire risk assessments, fire training

privacy / cookies

website cms powered by csb internet

we don't bite!
08000 838114 / 01832 735874